A “dishonest and manipulative” married man has been found guilty of the murder of a female student who went to his church.
Shohfah-El Israel, whose birth name is Ajibola Shogbamimu and is also a father, was convicted by a jury at Reading crown court for the killing of Joy Morgan after spending time alone with her – against strict church rules – in December.
The 20-year-old midwifery student’s body has never been recovered, despite extensive police searches of hundreds of hectares of land in Hertfordshire.
Israel was convicted by a jury of eight women and four men on a single count of murder.
He lied to the police when he was arrested, saying he had dropped Morgan off at her student accommodation in Hatfield after a celebratory dinner at the American-founded Israel United in Christ Church they attended in Ilford, east London, on 26 December.
He later admitted he had in fact spent two nights alone with the University of Hertfordshire student in his Cricklewood flat, but claimed his lies were due to concerns about having broken church rules banning women from being alone with men other than their husbands.
The court heard that after killing Morgan he attempted to cover his tracks by removing her number from a church group chat on the app Telegram, and even kept up the pretence by going to her student house share under the guise of checking on her in the days after she had gone missing.
A signal from Morgan’s phone, which has never been found, was detected in Israel’s car in the Stevenage area on 28 December, at which point the jury was told he was most likely “looking for somewhere to dispose of the body”.
Despite days of police searches in that area, Morgan’s body has not been found. The keys to her house were discovered in the footwell of his car after his arrest in February.
From the witness box he told the jury that Morgan – whom he denied having sex with, claiming he saw her as a daughter – had told him she wanted to leave the church.
But fellow worshippers told the court they were shocked by the idea that she might quit the church so suddenly, saying she had found the “familial love” there that she had been craving.
A video taken less than two weeks before she went missing saw her describe the church as “the best family that I’ve ever had”.
Despite church members saying they were surprised at her apparent departure, they did not report her missing. It was her mother Carol Morgan, who is not a member of the church, who reported her disappearance to police on 7 February, six weeks after she was last seen.
In a message sent in March 2018 Israel told Morgan she was an “amazing princess” and “a treasure that cannot be measured”.
The jury was not told about flirtatious exchanges Israel allegedly had with other women both before and after the student went missing.
Despite the image he presented of being an upstanding married member of the church he had in fact been using chat-up manuals, in some cases quoting directly from them, during his exchanges with women
Israel is originally from Nigeria but has lived in the UK for 22 years.
The court heard that Morgan had a difficult family background and had been reported missing previously in 2013 and 2014, but only for a day on each occasion.
Relatives, including her mother, were in court throughout the four-week trial.